German movies often illustrate negotiation as a process defined by structure, order, and factual analysis. Characters in positions of power tend to focus on rule-based arguments, logical reasoning, and procedural adherence. Emotional appeals are secondary to procedural integrity and factual evidence, revealing the German preference for consistency, predictability, and methodical negotiation processes.
What’s said is said.
Was gesagt ist, ist gesagt. What’s said is said. This statement emphasizes that you have to stand by your words. Once statements have been made, they are considered binding, and backtracking makes you appear unreliable and weak.
“Vertrag ist Vertrag”
Vertrag ist Vertrag. A contract is a contract. A contract is binding – period. Changes or renegotiations are often seen as unprofessional. This expression highlights the German preference for legal certainty and clear agreements.
“Auf Worte müssen Taten folgen”
Auf Worte müssen Taten folgen. Words must be followed by actions. Empty promises are useless. In German negotiation culture, it is expected that statements will be consistently put into practice.
Effi Briest
Effi Briest by Theodor Fontane (1896). In the confrontation between Geert von Instetten and Major Crampas, Instetten challenges Crampas to a duel after discovering that his wife Effi had an affair. The duel is framed as a matter of honor, duty, and adherence to societal rules. Instetten’s actions are driven not by personal anger but by a sense of obligation to maintain social order and follow protocol. The focus on duty, principle, and maintaining the integrity of agreements underscores the German tendency to adhere strictly to social norms and established structures.
Locarno Treaties (1925)
Gustav Stresemann, German Foreign Minister, played a key role in negotiating the Locarno Treaties, which aimed to stabilize post-WWI Europe. His approach was methodical and focused on building trust and establishing clear, fixed agreements to prevent future conflict, embodying the German preference for structure and legal certainty.
European Stability Mechanism (2012)
Wolfgang Schäuble, as Finance Minister, played a central role in negotiating the European Stability Mechanism. He was known for his strict, no-nonsense approach, insisting on clear financial rules and enforcement mechanisms, underscoring the German preference for contractual certainty and fiscal discipline.
Hauptmann Wiesler
In The Lives of Others, set in 1984 East Berlin, the Stasi secret police monitor playwright Georg Dreyman, suspecting him of anti-government activities. The Stasi officer, Hauptmann (captain) Wiesler, employs a methodical, structured approach during Dreyman’s interrogation.
Wiesler adheres strictly to protocol, asking precise, repetitive questions to expose inconsistencies. The scene is devoid of emotional appeals and is driven by logic, structure, and adherence to bureaucratic procedure. The emphasis on detailed questioning, factual evidence, and strict procedural adherence reflects the German preference for systematic, rule-based negotiation, even in coercive situations.
Andreas Baader
Andreas Baader, a leader of the Red Army Faction in then West Germany, negotiates with prison authorities regarding his imprisonment conditions. Baader adopts a direct, blunt, and confrontational style, emphasizing his ideological stance and refusing to compromise. The prison authorities, in contrast, stick to legal procedures, emphasizing structure, order, and adherence to established rules. The emphasis on procedure, legal frameworks, and strict adherence to protocol reflects the German approach to negotiation as a rule-bound, structured process, devoid of emotional influence.
Treaty of Versailles (1919)
Although the Treaty of Versailles was deeply resented in Germany, the Allied powers expected strict adherence to its terms, and Germany was held to a high standard of compliance. The German public and government viewed agreements – even highly unfavorable ones – as binding, and the expectation was that obligations would be fulfilled as stipulated, unless renegotiated through formal channels.