The conduct of a proof

Proof-leading. German separates the Beweis, the proof, from the Beweisführung, the conducting of it.

You can be right and have your Beweisführung attacked. The two are assessed separately, and the second is where the argument usually happens.

Whose competence

Zuständigkeit — competence, jurisdiction, the area for which one is responsible. German organisations and public bodies define it precisely, and disputes about it are real disputes. Dafür bin ich nicht zuständig is not an evasion. It is a statement about where the authority sits.

The duty to give reasons

Begründungspflicht. German courts and authorities are under a duty to give reasons. A judgment carries a Begründung — a grounding — as a mandatory part of the document, not a courtesy.

A decision without adequate reasons is defective as a decision, regardless of whether the outcome was right.

The reasoning is not an explanation of the ruling. It is part of it.

Actionable

An American business adjective applied to information, and used as a test rather than a description. Is this actionable? Information that fails it is not called wrong or incomplete. It is called interesting — which in that context is a dismissal.

Bang for the buck

Bang for the buck. You get what you pay for. Penny wise, pound foolish. Cheap is expensive.

Four American sayings about price and quality. All four assume the two are linked, and none of them describes quality as a thing that could be assessed on its own.

The vocabulary of made things

Wertarbeit — value-work. Craftsmanship, but the compound names the value rather than the craft.

Qualitätsarbeit, Wertigkeit, solide, gediegen — four more German words of approval for a made thing, and none of them is about appearance.

Billig und schlecht — cheap and bad, spoken as a single phrase, as though the two were the same observation.

Standing still

If you’re not moving forward, you’re moving backward. Standing still is falling behind. Plateaued. Stuck in the same role. Career stagnation.

American vocabulary treats the absence of advancement as an active condition requiring diagnosis, not as a settled state.

Able to be retraced

Literally: able to be travelled after. To be nachvollziehbar is to be such that another person can walk the same path and arrive at the same place.

English translates it as understandable or comprehensible, which loses the whole point. Those words describe a state in the listener. Nachvollziehbar describes a property of the reasoning — it can be retraced.

An argument that persuades but cannot be retraced has failed.

understand-culture
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.