Although the Treaty of Versailles was deeply resented in Germany, the Allied powers expected strict adherence to its terms, and Germany was held to a high standard of compliance. The German public and government viewed agreements – even highly unfavorable ones – as binding, and the expectation was that obligations would be fulfilled as stipulated, unless renegotiated through formal channels.
Renegotiation
Frequent Renegotiation and Non-Ratification of Treaties: The U.S. diplomatic history is marked by numerous instances where treaties were signed but not ratified, or where the U.S. reserved the right to renegotiate or withdraw—such as the failure to ratify the 1911 Reciprocity Treaty with Canada or the 1927 Naval Disarmament Conference in Geneva, which ended without agreement.
McDonald brothers
The Founder (2016). This film tells the story of Ray Kroc and the McDonald brothers. Kroc enters into an agreement with the brothers to franchise their restaurant, maintains constant contact as the business grows, but ultimately finds ways to change the terms and force the original owners out. The movie highlights how agreements can be transactional, with parties reserving the right to alter or exit arrangements when it suits their interests.
verbal vs. written
In the United States, a verbal agreement can be legally binding under certain circumstances. Contract law in the U.S. is governed by state laws as well as the principles outlined in the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) and common law precedents. For a verbal agreement to be legally enforceable, it must meet specific criteria, including offer and acceptance, consideration, and mutual intent to enter into a binding agreement. However, the enforceability of verbal agreements can vary based on the nature and value of the agreement.
Certain types of agreements, however, must be in writing to be legally enforceable. This requirement is based on the Statute of Frauds, which mandates that certain contracts must be in writing to prevent fraud and misunderstandings. Examples of such agreements include contracts involving the sale of real estate, agreements that cannot be performed within one year, contracts for the sale of goods valued over a certain amount as specified by the UCC, and agreements to pay someone else’s debt.
While verbal agreements are generally enforceable, proving the existence and specific terms of such agreements can be challenging. Courts may require clear and convincing evidence to substantiate a verbal contract. Testimonies, witness statements, and other forms of corroborative evidence can be considered, but the lack of written documentation often complicates enforcement.
Culturally, Americans may be more open to negotiating and entering into verbal agreements than in some other countries. However, in business and legal contexts, written contracts are typically preferred to minimize ambiguities and provide a tangible record of the agreed terms. While the law may recognize verbal agreements as binding, written agreements remain the standard practice, particularly in high-value transactions or complex contractual arrangements.
Military Aid to Ukraine
Modern German Political Decision-Making (e.g. Military Aid to Ukraine): Recent decisions, such as sending military aid to Ukraine or providing German-made tanks, have been characterized by lengthy internal debate and demands for contextual clarity. Germany’s government typically seeks broad consensus among coalition partners and ministries, and only acts after extensive information gathering and negotiation. Allies often note Germany’s hesitancy, but when a decision is finally made, it is highly committed and rarely reversed.
Peace of Augsburg
The Peace of Augsburg (1555): This treaty ended religious conflict within the Holy Roman Empire by allowing rulers to choose their territory’s religion. The agreement was reached only after protracted negotiations and careful consideration of the political and religious context. The resulting yes was highly binding and respected, reflecting the German preference for thorough context before agreement.
“Ein Mann, ein Wort”
Ein Mann, ein Wort. Literally, a man, a word. If you promise something, you have to keep it. This saying stands for reliability and consistency. A word is considered just as binding as a written contract.
walk away
“We can always walk away.” This direct statement illustrates the American logic that participation in an agreement is voluntary and can be ended if it no longer serves one’s interests.
chess match
The West Wing (1999-2006) presents a more politically nuanced depiction of negotiation in a scene where President Bartlet and his Chief of Staff, Leo McGarry, negotiate with congressional leaders over a contentious budget deal. Bartlet employs a strategic, results-driven approach, leveraging political capital and making calculated compromises to secure bipartisan support. The negotiation is framed as a chess match, with each side maneuvering strategically to secure key concessions. The scene illustrates the American emphasis on strategic negotiation as a means to achieve political objectives.
“Show him the money”
In Jerry Maguire, the negotiation between Jerry Maguire and Rod Tidwell encapsulates the American emphasis on assertiveness, personal branding, and relationship-building in business deals. Jerry, a sports agent, tries to persuade Rod, a professional football player, to sign with him by promising to ‘show him the money.’ The negotiation is characterized by emotional appeals, personal connection, and assertive, results-oriented language. Unlike more structured, logic-driven approaches, the scene underscores the importance of charisma and personality in American-style negotiation.