In 1770, John Wesley, the founder of Methodism, wrote a memorial sermon on the death of the preacher George Whitefield. It acknowledged the doctrinal differences between the two men but played them down: “There are many doctrines of a less essential nature … In these we may think and let think; we may ‘agree to disagree.'”
Wesley did not coin the phrase. Whitefield had used it by 1750, and an older form, agree to differ, appears in 1704.