It Is Wrong to Order Details

German fire brigades work under the service regulation FwDV 100 on leadership in operations. Its 1999 edition defines Auftragstaktik, mission tactics, as a concept of leadership that leaves the crews as much freedom as possible in carrying out the task. Entscheidend ist das Erreichen des vorgegebenen Ziels. What counts is reaching the given goal.

The order may be limited to a clear statement of that goal. The regulation also says: Es ist falsch, Einzelheiten zu befehlen, die die nachgeordneten Führungskräfte an Ort und Stelle besser übersehen. It is wrong to order details that the subordinate leaders on the spot can judge better.

The Air Traffic Controllers of 1973

Civil servants in Germany may not strike. Beginning on Ascension Day, 31 May 1973, and until the end of the year, West German air traffic controllers slowed down traffic at several German airports by Dienst nach Vorschrift, working strictly to the rules. German Wikipedia notes that this method let civil servants get around their ban on striking. The airlines put their losses at about 235 million marks.

In 1981 the Federal Administrative Court ruled that collective actions which reduce the work performed violate a civil servant’s duty to carry out the office conscientiously. In 1984 the federal government had to pay Lufthansa more than 113 million marks in damages for the “air traffic controllers’ action of 1973.”

Three Out of Four Work to Rule

Every year the polling company Gallup asks employees in Germany about their bond with their employer. In the 2024 survey of 1,700 employees, 78 percent had a low emotional bond. Gallup’s German press release describes them simply as people die Dienst nach Vorschrift machen, who work to rule. Only 9 percent had a high bond.

In the survey for 2025 the figures were 10 percent high, 77 percent low and 13 percent none. In this use, the term describes a lasting state of mind, not a protest.

Quiet Quitting Already Had a German Name

In August 2022, when “quiet quitting” spread on social media, the legal news site LTO asked the labor lawyer Michael Fuhlrott what it meant. Es lässt sich ins Deutsche am besten mit ‘Dienst nach Vorschrift’ übersetzen.

It is best translated into German as work to rule. The aim, he said, is not to harm the employer, and the employer’s legal options are very limited. German case law ties the duty to the person. The Federal Labor Court ruled in 2003 that an employee may not set the level of performance arbitrarily, but must work with appropriate use of his personal capacity.

Planning, Carrying Out, Checking

The training regulation for mechatronics technicians says that apprentices shall be enabled to do qualified work die insbesondere selbstständiges Planen, Durchführen und Kontrollieren einschließt, which includes in particular independent planning, carrying out and checking. The next sentence says that this ability must be proven in the examinations.

Who Plans the Work

In 2018, 64 percent of employees in Germany said they could often plan and organize their own work. In 2006 the figure had been 68 percent. Only 29 percent said they often had influence on the amount of work assigned to them.

The figures come from a large employment survey by two federal institutes, the BIBB for vocational training and the BAuA for occupational safety and health. The federal government reported them in 2019 in reply to a question from members of the Bundestag.

Subsidiarity

Subsidiarität, subsidiarity, means that what a smaller unit can do by itself should not be taken over by a larger one. A common short form is so niedrig wie möglich, so hoch wie nötig, as low as possible, as high as necessary. The classic formulation is in the papal encyclical Quadragesimo anno of 1931, which the Jesuit Oswald von Nell-Breuning and Gustav Gundlach drafted.

The larger community may support the smaller one, but it darf sie aber niemals zerschlagen oder aufsaugen, may never smash or absorb it. Under Article 23 of the Basic Law, Germany takes part in building a European Union that is committed to the principle. German youth welfare law gives recognized independent providers priority over public ones.

The Vocabulary of Being Watched

gängeln — to keep someone in leading strings, to patronize constantly. It comes from an old verb meaning “to make walk.”

bevormunden — to treat someone as a ward

jemanden an der kurzen Leine halten — to keep someone on a short leash

jemandem über die Schulter schauen — to look over someone’s shoulder

das Mikromanagement — micromanagement

der Kontrollfreak — the control freak

What Job Ads Ask For

In 2022 the Bertelsmann Stiftung analyzed more than 48 million online job advertisements in Germany. Einsatzbereitschaft, commitment, was required in nearly half of them. Teamfähigkeit, the ability to work in a team, appeared in just under a third.

Selbstständigkeit, independence, appeared in a quarter. The same word returns when the job ends. A very good German work reference says: Er arbeitete stets sehr selbstständig, zuverlässig und verantwortungsbewusst. He always worked very independently, reliably and responsibly.

Not the Letter of Your Will

Heinrich von Kleist wrote Prinz Friedrich von Homburg in 1809 and 1810. Before the battle of Fehrbellin the prince is told not to attack without an explicit order. He attacks anyway and wins. He is sentenced to death for disobedience.

Near the end of the play the old colonel Kottwitz defends him before the Elector. Herr, das Gesetz, das höchste, oberste, / Das wirken soll, in deiner Feldherrn Brust, / Das ist der Buchstab deines Willens nicht. Sir, the highest law that should work in your general’s breast is not the letter of your will.

Does the Elector want to make the army a tool, he asks, gleich dem Schwerte, / Das tot in deinem goldnen Gürtel ruht, like the sword that lies dead in your golden belt? The Elector asks in return: Meinst du das Glück werd immerdar, wie jüngst, / Mit einem Kranz den Ungehorsam lohnen? Do you think luck will always reward disobedience with a wreath, as it did just now?

understand-culture
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.