Under the Hartz IV reform, the Federal Employment Agency and the districts ran joint job centers for people on long-term benefits. On 20 December 2007 the Federal Constitutional Court ruled that the arrangement violated the districts’ right to perform their tasks on their own responsibility.
It also violated the principle of Verantwortungsklarheit, clarity of responsibility, because it prevented a clear attribution of state action to one of the two bodies. To keep the joint job centers, the Basic Law itself was amended in July 2010 with a new Article 91e.