Moral Maze is a live discussion program on BBC Radio 4, broadcast since 1990. The presenter, Michael Buerk, introduces a moral question. A series of witnesses, experts or other relevant people, are then questioned by a panel, who afterward discuss what each witness said.
The Cab-Rank Rule
Under the cab-rank rule, a barrister in England must accept any work in a field in which they profess to be competent, at a court where they normally appear and at their usual rates. The name comes from the taxi at the head of a queue, which must take the first passenger.
In 1792, defending Thomas Paine, Thomas Erskine said: “From the moment that any advocate can be permitted to say that he will or will not stand between the Crown and the subject arraigned in the court where he daily sits to practise, from that moment the liberties of England are at an end.”
I Agree with Nick
On 15 April 2010, the leaders of the three main parties met in Britain’s first televised election debate. Gordon Brown repeatedly said “I agree with Nick,” and the phrase became the catchphrase of the evening. Instant polls named the Liberal Democrat leader, Nick Clegg, the winner. One gave him 61 percent.
On polling day, the Liberal Democrat share of the vote rose by only one point, and the party lost five seats.
A Certainty That Was Not Justified
On 6 July 2016, Sir John Chilcot presented the report of the Iraq Inquiry. He said that the judgments about Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction “were presented with a certainty that was not justified.” He also stressed “the importance of collective Ministerial discussion which encourages frank and informed debate and challenge.”
The day after the report was published, Tony Blair conceded that he should have challenged the intelligence reports before relying on them.
The Vocabulary of Conceding
British English has several short phrases for giving ground in an argument. Point taken : I understand your objection. I take your point : I accept that the argument has force. I stand corrected : I was wrong.
The Vocabulary of Floating an Idea
At work, British colleagues often introduce an idea they have thought through as if it were barely formed.
This is probably a stupid idea, but: I have thought about this, and I think it is good.
Feel free to shoot this down: Please consider this seriously.
It’s a bit half-baked: It is not finished, and I would like help with it.
Just thinking out loud: This is not a formal proposal yet.
Off the top of my head: Here is a first answer, which may change.
I’m no expert, but: I have a view, and I will state it without claiming authority.
Have You Thought About
At work, British criticism often comes as a question or a suggestion.
Have you thought about…?: This needs to change.
I’m not sure I’d have gone that way: That was the wrong choice.
That’s one option: That is not the option I would choose.
I wonder whether…: You should.
It’s not quite there yet: It needs a lot more work.
With respect: I disagree.