In his essay “Rationalism in Politics,” first published in 1947, the philosopher Michael Oakeshott argued that practical knowledge “exists only in practice.” It “can be acquired only by continuous contact with one who is perpetually practicing it.”
More Than We Can Tell
The chemist and philosopher Michael Polanyi worked at the University of Manchester from 1933 to 1958. In The Tacit Dimension, published in 1966, he summed up the idea of tacit knowledge in one sentence: “we can know more than we can tell.”
The Knowledge
To drive a black cab in London, a driver must pass the Knowledge. Candidates learn the streets and landmarks within six miles of Charing Cross, about 25,000 streets in all. Transport for London says that mastering the Knowledge “typically takes students three to four years.”
In 2000, the neuroscientist Eleanor Maguire showed that a part of the brain, the hippocampus, is larger in London cab drivers.
I Really Do Not See the Signal
At the Battle of Copenhagen in 1801, the commander, Admiral Parker, flew a signal to break off the action. According to the famous story, Nelson said to his captain: “You know, Foley, I have only one eye, and I have the right to be blind sometimes.” He raised his telescope to his blind eye and said: “I really do not see the signal.”
Many historians treat the story as a legend. It comes from accounts written after Nelson’s death.
The Moment of Decision
In Reflections on the Revolution in France, published in 1790, Edmund Burke defended prejudice. “Prejudice renders a man’s virtue his habit,” he wrote. It “does not leave the man hesitating in the moment of decision, sceptical, puzzled, and unresolved.”
An Old Hand
British English has many phrases that treat long experience as a reason to trust someone’s judgment.
An old hand: Someone skilled through long experience.
To know the ropes: To understand how things are done.
A copper’s nose: A police officer’s instinct for when something is wrong.
To have a nose for something: To be good at noticing or finding it.
A gut feeling: A strong belief that cannot be fully explained.
Lying in State
In September 2022, around a quarter of a million people queued to see the coffin of Queen Elizabeth II lying in state in Westminster Hall. The queue could stretch for ten miles, and waiting times reached more than 25 hours. Each person received a numbered wristband showing when they had joined.
The former footballer David Beckham was among those who queued. He waited about twelve hours.
Polkey
On 19 November 1987, in Polkey v A E Dayton Services, the House of Lords ruled on unfair dismissal. A dismissal that is unfair for reasons of procedure does not become fair because it would probably have happened anyway.
Lord Bridge said that if an employer failed to take the appropriate procedural steps, the one question the tribunal “is not permitted to ask” is “whether it would have made any difference to the outcome.”
Catching the Speaker’s Eye
In the House of Commons, “MPs may speak only if they are called to do so by the Speaker.” They show that they want to speak by standing up briefly each time the next MP is about to be called.
The Commons guide to rules of behavior states that the choice of speakers is at the discretion of the Chair. “The objective at all times is to give all Members a fair opportunity to take part in debate.”
Mr Bates vs The Post Office
From 1 January 2024, ITV broadcast the drama Mr Bates vs The Post Office on four consecutive days. It told the story of subpostmasters prosecuted on the evidence of faulty Post Office software, Horizon.
The drama made the scandal a major political issue. In May 2024, Parliament passed the Post Office (Horizon System) Offences Act, which quashed the convictions. A government letter later stated that “hundreds of convictions of innocent postmasters have been quashed.”