The Cologne Declaration

In January 1989, 163 Catholic theologians signed the Kölner Erklärung, the Cologne Declaration. Its title was Wider die Entmündigung – für eine offene Katholizität, against being treated as minors, for an open catholicity. The signers criticized what they saw as the authoritarian style of the church leadership under Pope John Paul II.

They asked that local churches have a stronger part in appointing bishops. One occasion was the appointment of Cardinal Joachim Meisner as Archbishop of Cologne. The signers said they wanted to contribute to a serious theological conversation. In all, more than 700 theologians worldwide supported it.

The Vocabulary of Respectful Objection

Mit Verlaub — by your leave, if you permit

Bei allem Respekt — with all due respect

Das sehe ich anders. — I see that differently.

Da muss ich widersprechen. — I have to contradict you there.

der Einwand — the objection

Widerworte geben — to answer back

Keine Widerworte! — No answering back! This is what the person in charge says to end it.

The Supervisory Board May Not Manage

The Stock Corporation Act says: Der Vorstand hat unter eigener Verantwortung die Gesellschaft zu leiten. The management board runs the company on its own responsibility. The supervisory board oversees it, but management measures cannot be transferred to the supervisory board.

It may only require that certain kinds of transactions need its consent. The shareholders’ meeting may decide a question of management only if the management board asks it to. In a limited liability company, the GmbH, the arrangement is different. There the managing directors must observe the limits that the shareholders set.

Piëch Keeps His Distance

On 10 April 2015 Ferdinand Piëch, chair of Volkswagen’s supervisory board, told Der Spiegel: Ich bin auf Distanz zu Winterkorn. I am keeping my distance from Winterkorn. Martin Winterkorn was the company’s chief executive. A week later, the presidium of the supervisory board called Winterkorn the best possible chief executive and proposed extending his contract.

According to the news agency dpa, the other five members of the presidium all stood against Piëch. On 25 April Piëch resigned from all his posts at Volkswagen with immediate effect.

Bismarck and the Order of 1852

A Prussian cabinet order of 8 September 1852 regulated the position of the minister-president toward the other ministers. In March 1890 Kaiser Wilhelm II demanded that Otto von Bismarck draft an order to repeal it. Bismarck refused. In his letter of resignation of 18 March 1890 he argued that unified policy was impossible wenn jeder einzelne Minister allerhöchste Anordnungen extrahieren kann, if each individual minister can extract orders from the monarch.

He wrote that he was außerstande, Euerer Majestät Befehl auszuführen, unable to carry out Your Majesty’s command. The dispute over the order was the formal occasion of his dismissal. The two men were also divided over social policy and the Social Democrats.

A Low Point in Federal Culture

In April 2021 the federal government took over part of the Covid rules from the states. Under the Bundesnotbremse, the federal emergency brake, curfews, contact limits and other measures applied automatically in any district where the seven-day incidence was above 100 on three consecutive days. The Bundestag passed the law on 21 April 2021. The next day the Bundesrat, the chamber of the states, let it pass.

Its president, Reiner Haseloff, the premier of Saxony-Anhalt, said: Der heutige Tag ist für mich ein Tiefpunkt in der föderalen Kultur der Bundesrepublik Deutschland. For me, today is a low point in the federal culture of the Federal Republic of Germany. An objection by the states, he said, would only have delayed the law, not improved or prevented it. The law expired on 30 June 2021.

The Ban on Cooperation

Since the federalism reform of 2006, the Basic Law has kept the federal government out of the states’ school policy, in particular by not allowing it to finance education measures. Germans call this the Kooperationsverbot, the ban on cooperation. To let federal money flow into school digitalization, the Basic Law had to be amended. The Bundesrat approved the change unanimously on 15 March 2019.

Even now, the federal government may help the states only with investments in municipal education infrastructure and with temporary spending directly tied to them. In a 2020 survey by the ifo Institute, 60 percent of respondents said the federal government should in principle make the important decisions in education policy.

Wages Are Not the State’s Business

Article 9 of the Basic Law protects the right to form associations to improve working and economic conditions. From it follows the Tarifautonomie, under which unions and employers set wages free from state interference. A statutory minimum wage arrived only on 1 January 2015, at 8.50 euros an hour. Its adjustments were left to a commission in which unions and employers each have three voting members.

In 2022 the Bundestag instead raised the minimum wage by law, to 12 euros from 1 October. When the plan was presented, the president of the employers’ federation BDA, Rainer Dulger, called it a grobe Verletzung der Tarifautonomie, a gross violation of bargaining autonomy. The federation complained that the increase was set without the commission that was actually responsible.

The Coach and the Sporting Director

In January 2020 Hansi Flick, head coach of Bayern Munich, publicly called for new players. The club’s sporting director, Hasan Salihamidžić, answered: Ich bin einfach kein Freund von medialer Kaderplanung. I am simply not a fan of planning the squad through the media.

Disagreements between the two continued through the 2020–21 season. The club’s board disapproved of Flick’s one-sided communication. On 17 April 2021 Flick announced that he wanted to leave his contract in the summer.

Judges Answer Only to the Law

Article 97 of the Basic Law: Die Richter sind unabhängig und nur dem Gesetze unterworfen. Judges are independent and subject only to the law. Judges still have a superior for administrative matters. The German Judges Act limits that supervision: Der Richter untersteht einer Dienstaufsicht nur, soweit nicht seine Unabhängigkeit beeinträchtigt wird.

A judge is subject to supervision only as far as it does not impair his independence. The superior may point out an improper manner of handling official business, and may urge orderly and timely work. Anything that would impair the judge’s independence is outside the superior’s reach.

understand-culture
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.