Fair and Reasonable in All the Circumstances

Under section 228 of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000, a complaint to the Financial Ombudsman Service is decided “by reference to what is, in the opinion of the ombudsman,” “fair and reasonable in all the circumstances of the case.”

The ombudsman says it is “required to take into account relevant law (among other things).” A Court of Appeal summary lists “law and regulation, regulators’ rules, guidance and standards, codes of practice” and good industry practice.

Inherently Repugnant

In Walford v Miles, decided in 1992, the House of Lords refused to enforce an agreement to negotiate in good faith. Lord Ackner said that “the concept of a duty to carry on negotiations in good faith is inherently repugnant to the adversarial position of the parties when involved in negotiations.”

In 2013, in Yam Seng v International Trade Corporation, Mr Justice Leggatt held that some “relational” contracts carry an implied duty of good faith. Such contracts rest on “communication, co-operation and predictable performance based on mutual trust and confidence.”

A duty to negotiate in good faith remains unenforceable.

Di Canio Catches the Ball

On 16 December 2000, West Ham United played Everton in the Premier League. The Everton goalkeeper, Paul Gerrard, “was lying injured on the floor.” A cross reached the West Ham striker Paolo Di Canio in front of the open goal. He “picked the ball up rather than continuing.”

FIFA gave him its Fair Play Award for 2001, for “a special act of good sportsmanship.”

Applying One’s Own Penalties

The R&A publishes the Rules of Golf. Rule 1 sets standards of player conduct. Players are expected to act with integrity, “for example, by following the Rules, applying all penalties.”

The rule adds: “Players are expected to recognize when they have breached a Rule and to be honest in applying their own penalties.”

Legal, Decent, Honest and Truthful

The Advertising Standards Authority regulates advertising in the United Kingdom. It describes its origin this way: “We were established in 1962 to keep UK advertising ‘legal, decent, honest and truthful’.”

Rule 1.1 of the advertising code still reads: “Marketing communications should be legal, decent, honest and truthful.”

Bodyline

During England’s cricket tour of Australia in 1932 and 1933, the tactics of the England captain, Douglas Jardine, became known as Bodyline. On 18 January 1933, the Australian cricket board cabled the MCC: “In our opinion it is unsportsmanlike.”

The MCC replied: “We deplore your cable.”

Sticking to the Letter

British English has many unkind words for a person who insists on the exact terms.

A jobsworth: An official who applies small rules to the letter, whatever the result.

A stickler: A person who insists on exact rules.

A barrack-room lawyer: A person who argues over the wording of rules, usually to avoid a duty.

A box-ticking exercise: Following a procedure without caring about its purpose.

That’s a bit petty: That is technically correct but unreasonable.

It’s not cricket: It is unfair, even if it is allowed.

Fair and Reasonable

The Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 subjects many contract terms to a requirement of reasonableness. Section 11 defines it. The term must have been “a fair and reasonable one to be included,” given the circumstances the parties knew, or ought reasonably to have known, when the contract was made.

A clause can be clearly worded and signed, and still fail this test.

Consumer Duty

Since 31 July 2023, financial firms in the United Kingdom have been bound by the Financial Conduct Authority’s Consumer Duty. Its central principle, Principle 12, reads: “A firm must act to deliver good outcomes for retail customers.” Supporting rules require firms to act in good faith toward customers.

The FCA warned firms not to treat the Duty as a tick-box exercise.

understand-culture
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.