Comply or Explain

In December 1992, the Cadbury Committee published its report and code on corporate governance. A company did not have to follow every provision of the code. It could comply, or explain why it had chosen not to.

The code of the Financial Reporting Council states that it “does not set out a rigid set of rules.” In 2012, Sir Adrian Cadbury called comply or explain “the most enduring legacy of the Committee’s work.”

Too Much Prescriptive Law

In July 1972, a committee chaired by Lord Robens reported on safety and health at work. According to the British Safety Council, it found “too much prescriptive law of the wrong kind which itself generated apathy.”

The Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974 followed. The British Safety Council describes the result as a “simpler, goalsetting, outcome-based, regulatory framework.”

Principles for Businesses

Broad principles have been part of British financial regulation since 1990. The Principles for Businesses of the Financial Conduct Authority begin with two short sentences. Principle 1: “A firm must conduct its business with integrity.” Principle 2 asks a firm to act with due skill, care and diligence.

Approved Documents

In England, the Building Regulations set legal requirements for buildings. The government publishes guidance on meeting them in a series of Approved Documents.

The guidance is not compulsory. A council building control service explains that “the guidance in the documents is not statutory and does not have to be followed.” The construction reference site Designing Buildings puts it this way: “There is no obligation to adopt the solutions presented in the approved documents.”

The Generalist Scheme

The Civil Service Fast Stream is the graduate entry program of the British civil service. According to the Institute for Government, “Historically, the single largest scheme was the Generalist scheme, which did not correspond to any specific profession.”

Fast streamers “will usually rotate across departments, with most postings lasting a year.” The current Government Policy scheme tells applicants: “You will work across a range of departments and roles.”

A Free Hand

British English has many approving phrases for leaving people to do their work.

To give someone a free hand: To let someone decide how to do a job.

To give someone free rein: To give someone wide freedom to act.

To let someone get on with it: To stop checking and let the work proceed.

Why keep a dog and bark yourself?: There is no point in paying someone to do a job and then doing it yourself. The proverb is recorded from the late sixteenth century.

At Arm’s Length

On 12 July 1945, the economist John Maynard Keynes announced on BBC radio that the Arts Council of Great Britain would be “a permanent body, independent in constitution, free from red tape.” Keynes is also credited with the line: “The task of an official body is not to censor, but give courage, confidence and opportunity.”

Keynes arranged for the council to report to the Treasury. This established what came to be called an “arms length” relationship between arts policy and the government of the day.

The Government Will Set the Target

On 6 May 1997, the new Chancellor of the Exchequer, Gordon Brown, announced that the Bank of England would control interest rates. On 20 May, he explained the arrangement to the House of Commons. “The Government will set the inflation target for the Bank,” he said. “The Bank will have operational responsibility to achieve the inflation target.”

Decisions “on what actions need to be taken to achieve the target,” he added, “will be taken by a Monetary Policy Committee.”

understand-culture
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.