Economical with the Truth

In 1986, Sir Robert Armstrong, the Cabinet Secretary, gave evidence in the Supreme Court of New South Wales in Sydney, in the Spycatcher trial. Under cross-examination by Malcolm Turnbull, then a barrister, he said that a letter contained “a misleading impression,” not a lie. “A lie is a straight untruth,” he said. Then he added: “As one person said, it is perhaps being economical with the truth.”

The phrase was not his own. Edmund Burke had written of an “oeconomy of truth” in the 1790s. Within weeks of the trial, MPs were using “economical with the truth” in the House of Commons.

A Scratch

In Act 3 of Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, Mercutio is stabbed in a street fight. Asked whether he is hurt, he answers: “Ay, ay, a scratch, a scratch. Marry, ’tis enough.”

The wound kills him before the end of the scene. Even then he keeps up the joke. He calls his killer a “cat, to scratch a man to death!”

Not British Airways’ Finest Hour

Terminal 5 at Heathrow Airport opened on 27 March 2008. According to a report by the Commons Transport Committee, 36,584 passengers were affected by problems on the first day. According to British Airways, 23,205 bags had to be sorted by hand before they could be returned to their owners. The next day, Willie Walsh, chief executive of British Airways, said: “Yesterday was definitely not British Airways’ finest hour.”

At a hearing of the Transport Committee in May 2008, he said: “It is clear we made mistakes and compromised on the testing regime.”

Signing the Official Secrets Act

In 1989, the Department of Employment told Parliament that its staff were asked to sign a declaration, on joining and on leaving, that summarized the Official Secrets Act 1911. The Official Secrets Act 1989 replaced section 2 of the 1911 Act with provisions “protecting more limited classes” of official information.

In 1994, a minister told Parliament that employees “are no longer required to sign an ‘Official Secrets Act Declaration’.” In everyday British English, to have “signed the Official Secrets Act” still means to be bound to silence.

Compartmentalized Knowledge

At Bletchley Park, the British codebreaking center of the Second World War, staff were “sworn to secrecy: never to talk about their work.” The codebreaker Oliver Lawn later said that “the compartmentalisation of knowledge was particular to Bletchley Park.”

The work stayed secret for decades. It was first revealed in the 1970s by F. W. Winterbotham, a former insider, in his book The Ultra Secret. Lady Marion Body, who had worked at Bletchley, never told her husband. “I remember we could never speak about it and I had never done,” she said.

Privy Council Terms

By custom, the Leader of the Opposition becomes a member of the Privy Council. Privy counsellors swear an oath to keep secret the matters committed to them. This allows the government to brief them in confidence, usually on national security, on “privy council terms.”

The Institute for Government cites a meeting in 2003, at which Tony Blair discussed the evidence on Iraqi weapons with Iain Duncan Smith. In 2018, after the Salisbury poisoning, Jeremy Corbyn “was extended a briefing on the attack under privy council rules.”

A Service That Did Not Exist

In May 1992, according to the civil liberties group Statewatch, John Major “became the first Prime Minister to admit that MI6 actually existed.” MI6 is the British foreign intelligence service.

The service’s own website gives a later date: “The Intelligence Services Act 1994 was the first public acknowledgement of the existence of both MI6 and GCHQ.” The sources differ on which step counts as the first admission.

DSMA-Notices

Since 1912, the British media have worked with a system of notices on defense information, first known as D-Notices and since 2015 as DSMA-Notices. “The DSMA-Notice System is a means of providing advice and guidance to the media about defence and security information.” The advice comes from a committee “composed of senior civil servants and editors.”

The committee states: “The system is voluntary, it has no legal authority.” The decision to publish stays with each editor.

The Thirty-Year Rule

Under the Public Records Act 1958, British government records were closed to the public for fifty years. In 1967, the closure period was cut to thirty years.

In 2013, the government began to reduce the period from thirty to twenty years. Files from 1983 were released in August 2013.

Nincompoop

In his memoir A Journey, published in 2010, Tony Blair looked back on the Freedom of Information Act 2000, passed while he was prime minister. He wrote: “You idiot. You naive, foolish, irresponsible, nincompoop.” He added: “I quake at the imbecility of it.”

understand-culture
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.