In 1978, Joel Barnett devised a formula for funding Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland from the Treasury. In the House of Lords on 7 November 2001, he said that “it did not occur to me at the time that it would become a formula, or that it would last so long.” He also said: “I had always assumed that the arrangement would be temporary until a more sophisticated method could be devised.”
When Barnett died in 2014, the formula was still in use.