This Long Island Story

In late May 1940, with the British army cornered at Dunkirk, the War Cabinet was divided. The Foreign Secretary, Lord Halifax, wanted to explore whether Italy might mediate with Germany. On 28 May, Winston Churchill, prime minister for less than three weeks, met the 25 ministers outside the War Cabinet.

According to the diary of one of them, Hugh Dalton, Churchill said: “If this long island story of ours is to end at last, let it end only when each one of us lies, choking in his own blood upon the ground.” Dalton wrote: “No one expressed even the faintest flicker of dissent.” Churchill reported their support to the War Cabinet, which then rejected the approach to Italy.

COBR

In a national emergency, British ministers meet in COBR, the Cabinet Office Briefing Rooms in Whitehall. The name is also used for the committee itself, often called Cobra.

The Institute for Government notes that, unlike other cabinet committees, “it has no standing attendance list.” Ministers from the departments concerned meet with officials and agency staff, and with ministers from the devolved governments and regional mayors where relevant.

The Multidisciplinary Team

At King’s College Hospital, an NHS hospital in London, a cancer patient’s care is planned by a multidisciplinary team, or MDT. Its core members include a surgeon, an oncologist, a radiologist, a histopathologist and a clinical nurse specialist.

The team reviews the patient’s results at dedicated meetings. It “recommends the most appropriate treatment for you based on the best available evidence.”

The Governor Outvoted

Interest rates in the United Kingdom are set by the Bank of England’s Monetary Policy Committee, which has nine members. “Each individual member gets a vote, and the decision is based on the policy with a majority of votes.” The Governor decides only when the vote is tied.

In June 2007, the Governor, Mervyn King, was one of four members who voted to raise rates. Five voted to hold them, and the rate stayed at 5.5 percent. According to The Irish Times, it was the second time in the committee’s history that the Governor had been on the losing side.

Agreement to Differ

In 1975, the United Kingdom held a referendum on whether to stay in the European Economic Community. On 23 January 1975, Prime Minister Harold Wilson told the House of Commons that ministers who disagreed with the Cabinet’s eventual recommendation would be “free to support and speak in favour of a different conclusion in the referendum campaign”.

This would apply “only if there is not complete unanimity in the Cabinet on this question”. Wilson cited a precedent from the early 1930s, a Liberal “agreement to differ.”

Climate Assembly UK

In 2019, six select committees of the House of Commons commissioned Climate Assembly UK. Between January and May 2020, 108 members of the public met over six weekends to consider one question: “How should the UK meet its target of net zero greenhouse gas emissions by 2050?” The assembly published its report in September 2020.

The Vote on Syria

On 29 August 2013, the House of Commons voted against military action in Syria. David Cameron, the prime minister, told the House: “It is clear to me that the British Parliament, reflecting the views of the British people, does not want to see British military action. I get that, and the government will act accordingly.”

No law required the government to ask Parliament. In 2011, the government had acknowledged that “a convention exists that Parliament will be given the opportunity to debate the decision to commit troops.” The House of Commons Library describes the vote on Iraq on 18 March 2003 as the first example in modern times of prior approval being sought and granted.

A Certainty That Was Not Justified

On 6 July 2016, Sir John Chilcot presented the report of the Iraq Inquiry. He said that the judgments about Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction “were presented with a certainty that was not justified.” He also stressed “the importance of collective Ministerial discussion which encourages frank and informed debate and challenge.”

The day after the report was published, Tony Blair conceded that he should have challenged the intelligence reports before relying on them.

understand-culture
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.